Court of Appeals of Washington August 24, 1987, Nos. 15571-7-I; 17554-8-I (State v. Mott)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-08-1987

Webster, J.

Jack Eury Mott presents two matters for this court's consideration. The first is his direct appeal from a trial court order denying his motion to amend and dismissing a personal restraint petition (PRP) that had been remanded to the trial court for a determination on the merits. Consolidated with the direct appeal is the second of two PRP's that Mott has filed. In his second PRP Mott challenges the validity of a 1978 guilty plea. He argues that the plea is invalid because, when it was entered, he was unaware of his right to remain silent and of the legal defenses available to him. We affirm the trial court's dismissal of Mott's first PRP and remand his second PRP for a determination on the merits.

Facts Relating to Mott's Direct Appeal

Pursuant to a plea bargain agreement, Mott pleaded guilty in 1978 to second degree murder. In 1983 he filed a pro se PRP in which the sole ground for relief alleged was that the State had breached the plea bargain agreement. The acting chief judge referred Mott's petition to the superior court for a determination on the merits pursuant to RAP 16.11(a). According to the chief judge's order of remand, the meritorious issues presented were the "terms of the plea bargain agreement, whether the plea bargain agreement had been breached, and, if so, what relief should be granted petitioner." Following a trial court hearing, Mott's petition was denied. Mott does not appeal from the manner in which the trial court disposed of the issues listed in the order of remand.

Rather, Mott appeals from the trial court's refusal to consider issues raised for the first time during the course of the trial court hearing. These new issues were raised when Mott's appointed counsel filed in the superior court both a *117motion for leave to amend the original PRP and a proposed amended PRP. Holding that the superior court lacked jurisdiction to consider the amendment to the PRP, the trial judge reached none of the merits of the newly raised issues.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.