Court of Appeals of Oregon March 11, 1987, 144,280; CA A37898 (Tarwater v. Cupp)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-03-1987
WARDEN, P. J.
Petitioner was convicted in a jury trial on two counts each of second degree kidnapping and first degree rape and three counts of first degree sodomy. Consecutive sentences were imposed, with a minimum sentence of 30 years under ORS 144.110. He sought post-conviction relief, ORS 138.510, on the grounds that he had had ineffective assistance of trial counsel and that the written sentencing order differed from the court’s oral pronouncement from the bench. The post-conviction court denied relief.
Petitioner first contends that the jury instructions given on the rape and sodomy counts were improper, because they are “acquittal first” instructions, citing State v. Ogden, 35 Or App 91, 580 P2d 1049 (1978), and that he had ineffective assistance of trial counsel, because counsel failed to except to the giving of those instructions. We agree.
The instruction given stated:
“ [Although [petitioner] is charged [with the first degree offense], you have the right to determine * * * that [he] has committed a crime of lesser degree, provided that you are not satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that he has committed the crime as charged, but you are satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that he has committed a crime of lesser degree.” (Emphasis supplied.)
It told the jurors that they should consider the lesser-included offenses only if they did not find petitioner guilty of the first degree offenses beyond a reasonable doubt. The court erred in giving that instruction, because it required the jury to reach a verdict on the offenses charged before considering any lesser-included offenses. State v. Martin, 64 Or App 469, 471, 668 P2d 479 (1983); State v. Ogden, supra. Petitioner’s counsel’s failure to except to the giving of that instruction constitutes ineffective assistance of counsel. Peaslee v. Keeney, 81 Or App 488, 491-492, 726 P2d 398 (1986), rev den 302 Or 571 (1987). The post-conviction court therefore erred in denying relief.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit