District Court of Appeal of Florida September 9, 1987, No. BQ-169 (Avera v. Provident Security Life Insurance Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-09-1987

ERVIN, Judge.

The appellants (attorneys) appeal the trial court’s ruling granting final summary judgment in favor of the appellees. We hold that there exist genuine issues of material fact as to the appellants’ joint and several liability, and therefore find that summary judgment was improperly granted.

In September 1982, Stanley and Shirley Schofield were injured in an automobile accident. During the pendency of their claim in negligence against the third-party tortfeasor, the Schofields sought medical benefits under a group life insurance and health protection plan issued by Provident Security Life Insurance Company (Provident) through Stanley Schofield’s employer, Watkins Associated Industries (Watkins). A dispute arose between the parties regarding the subrogation rights of Watkins under the terms of the policy in the pending negligence action, and the Schofields filed a complaint for declaratory judgment, requesting the court to define the rights and liabilities of the parties. The complaint stated that as a condition precedent to the payment of benefits under the policy of insurance, Provident had insisted that the Schofields sign an agreement to refund group medical expense benefits if a claim for damages against a third-party tort-feasor was successful. The Schofields stated that under Section 627.7372, Florida Statutes, they were precluded from receiving payment from a tortfeasor for benefits already received from any collateral source, and therefore were not required to refund the insurance company for any amount of damages received in a third-party suit for damages. The complaint for declaratory judgment further stated that if the Schofields were to sign an agreement to refund group medical expenses, they would be put in the position of having to refund benefits to the insurance company, while also being statutorily precluded from recovering such benefits from the tort-feasors in the accident, thus resulting in a net loss.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.