Nevada Supreme Court May 29, 1987, No. 17425 (Vosburg Equipment v. Zupancic)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-05-1987
*267OPINION
By the Court,
Springer, J.:
This action was brought by appellants Vosburg, Galliher, and Mclnnis,1 to be called “Plaintiffs,” against respondent Zupancie, to be called “Defendant.” Plaintiffs sued defendant for breach of an oral agreement in which the four parties agreed to share equally in attorneys’ fees and court costs and to share equally in any recovery from their claims against Clark County. Plaintiffs’ and defendants’ independent tort claims arose out of flood damage to the four parties’ property.
Although defendant claimed that the agreement of the parties was too indefinite to be enforced, the district court found that the parties had “orally agreed to share equally in the total amount recovered, and to continue to finance the litigation by each paying one-fourth (V4) of the costs and attorney’s fees.” There is substantial evidence from the testimony of witness Lee, and of Vosburg, Galliher, and Mclnnis to support the district court’s finding that the parties did agree to divide equally “any recovery” as opposed to Zupancie’s claim that the agreement was to divide only those proceeds from a trial judgment.
A contract should be construed, if logically and legally permissible, so as to effectuate valid contractual relations, rather than in a manner which would render the agreement invalid, or render performance impossible. Reno Club, Inc. v. Young Investment *268Co., 64 Nev. 312, 182 P.2d 1011 (1947); cf. Morelli v. Morelli, 102 Nev. 326, 720 P.2d 704 (1986).
Holding, as we do, that there was a subsisting contract among the parties, the only issue remaining is to decide whether the trial judge erred in ruling, sua sponte, that such an agreement was by its very nature champertous and therefore unenforceable at law. We conclude that the contract was not champertous and that the contract is enforceable. The case is remanded to the district court for entry of judgment in plaintiffs’ favor.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit