Nevada Supreme Court September 30, 1987, No. 17732 (Lipitt v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-09-1987

*413OPINION

Per Curiam:

Plaintiff Allan Lipitt sued the State, several cities and their respective officials (hereinafter “cities”) as a result of his termination as the head of the CETA program in Las Vegas. The district court dismissed his claims for wrongful termination and we upheld this determination in an earlier appeal. The State was dismissed by stipulation. However, his claims for assault, battery and infliction of emotional distress against the cities were not dismissed and are at issue now. The cities moved to have these remaining claims dismissed under the mandatory five year dismissal provisions of NRCP 41(e). We affirm the district court’s order of dismissal.

The cities argue that the five year time limit for prosecution of an action under NRCP 41(e) ran before the May 9, 1986 hearing so that dismissal was mandatory. (The complaint was filed on June 17, 1980.) Rule 41(e) provides, as relevant, that an action must be dismissed if it is not brought to trial within five years after it was filed unless the parties have stipulated in writing that time may be extended. Lipitt contends, on the other hand, that dismissal was not mandated under the rule until three years after entry of our April 21, 1983 order dismissing the earlier appeals. See Massey v. Sunrise Hospital, 102 Nev. 367, 724 P.2d 208 (1986); NRCP 41(e). Judgment on our order was filed May 11, 1983, in district court. Thus, Lipitt had until May 11, 1986, to continue to prosecute his action. We conclude he did not succeed in bringing the matter to trial within the required time period.

Lipitt argues that the case was “brought to trial” within the time limits of Rule 41(e) because he called a witness1 at the May 9 hearing.2 We have held that a litigant who obtains a trial date within the statutory period, appears for trial in good faith, argues motions and examines jurors, thereby brings the case to trial. Smith v. Timm, 96 Nev. 197, 606 P.2d 530 (1980).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.