Supreme Court of New Hampshire October 15, 1987, No. 86-349 (State v. Bujnowski)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-10-1987
Thayer, J.
The defendant, Richard Bujnowski, was convicted by a jury of aggravated felonious sexual assault upon his ten-year-old stepson. RSA 632-A:2, XI. The Trial Court (Pappagianis, J.) sentenced the defendant to the New Hampshire State Prison for not less than five years and not more than fifteen years. The defendant appeals his conviction on the ground that the trial court erred in not granting a mistrial because the State severely prejudiced the defendant’s right to a fair trial by (1) making improper statements to the jury during its opening and closing statements, and (2) failing to produce an investigative police report. Because we find that the prosecutor’s improper statements in closing argument require reversal, we need not address the other issues presented by this appeal.
The sordid details of this child molestation case need not be set forth. It is sufficient to examine only the circumstances surrounding the State’s closing argument to the jury. During trial, the defense called the defendant’s wife to testify with respect, among other things, to statements made by the victim that the assault *3never took place and that the story was a fabrication. In his closing argument, the prosecutor commented on Mrs. Bujnowski’s testimony:
“There were some inconsistencies in her testimony, and that it’s not unreasonable to ask, was she telling the truth in everything she said? And I think for ninety-nine percent of it she was lying. I think she’s here to protect her husband.”
(Emphasis added.) At this point, defense counsel requested a conference at the bench. The defendant objected to the prosecutor’s statements and moved for a mistrial. The court denied the defendant’s motion, but agreed to give a curative instruction at the close of the State’s argument. Out of the hearing of the jury, the court instructed counsel that:
“There are cases which say the lawyer, in this case a prosecutor, should not give his personal opinion.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit