U S Air Force Court of Military Review September 30, 1987, ACM 25996 (United States v. Robinson)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-09-1987

DECISION

LEWIS, Judge:

In a trial before a military judge, sitting alone, the appellant was found guilty, consistent with his pleas, of burglary and unlawful entry of dormitory rooms, indecent assaults against two female airmen, disorderly conduct by wrongfully entering a women’s latrine, and resisting apprehension. The appellant’s pleas were entered pursuant to a pretrial agreement which, among other things, limited approval of a punitive discharge to a bad conduct discharge and confinement to 16 months. His sentence as adjudged and subsequently approved consisted of a bad conduct discharge, confinement for 11 months, forfeiture of $426.00 per month for 11 months and reduction to airman basic. The issue before us is whether his pretrial agreement improperly limited a right at trial, thereby requiring that we find his pleas improvident. For reasons set forth herein, we find that the appellant’s rights at trial were not improperly limited.

A provision in the written offer for pretrial agreement, which was incorporated into the resulting agreement upon its acceptance by the convening authority, obligated the appellant and his counsel “[n]ot to object to the introduction of A1C [J’s] and Amn [A’s] video tape statements during the sentencing portion of the trial.” During the sentencing portion of the trial the trial counsel played a video tape of a sworn statement by A1C J, one of the two victims of indecent assault. No objection was posed by the trial defense counsel to *529the introduction of the tape nor to any portion of its content. The tape had been recorded in a courtroom environment and consisted of A1C J responding to questions posed by an individual beyond camera range concerning the impact of the offense on her. By way of a very brief summary, A1C J stated that she had experienced extreme anxiety and nervousness as a result of the assault and had sought assistance of mental health personnel at the urging of her commander and her father.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.