District Court, District of Columbia April 7, 1987, Civ. A. No. 84-2371 (Skirlick v. Patco)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-04-1987

MEMORANDUM OPINION

SPORKIN, District Judge.

I. Introduction

This is an action on a bond. Plaintiffs are air traffic controllers who did not join their fellow Professional Air Traffic Controllers Organization (“PATCO”) members in the 1981 air traffic controllers strike.1 They are suing to recover on a surety bond carried on their union leaders. Their theory is that by conducting an illegal strike, the union leaders engaged in activity covered by the bond2 and that therefore, the bonding company must honor its commitment.

The bonding company — the only defendant left in the case — interposes four defenses as a matter of law: first, that plaintiffs have no standing since only the union’s trustee in bankruptcy can bring a claim on the bond; second, that plaintiffs have failed to fulfill the conditions precedent on the bond; third, that the acts complained of do not constitute “fraud or dishonesty” in the handling of funds, which is what the bond covers; and fourth, that plaintiffs knew of similar behavior by the PATCO officers in the past — that is, an earlier strike engaged in by those leaders— about which they did not inform the defendant, and thus they are now barred from bringing this claim. Because I find that the plaintiffs’ action was not timely filed and that the bond at issue was not intended to cover the actions complained of, I grant defendant’s motion for summary judgment and need not reach the other issues raised by the defendants.

*106II. Timeliness

Defendant alleges that the plaintiffs have failed to comply with two provisions in the bond agreement relating to the time for bringing an action on the bond. First, the bond requires that the insured file a detailed proof of loss, duly sworn to, with defendant, within four months after the discovery of loss. Second, the bond provides that no action shall lie against the defendant “at all unless commenced within one year from the date when the Insured discovers the loss.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.