Supreme Court of Iowa March 16, 1988, 87-114 (Heaton v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-03-1988
SCHULTZ, Justice.
David Heaton was convicted of first-degree murder in 1981 following a bench trial. We affirmed that conviction in a 1982 unpublished opinion. Heaton later challenged the conviction by filing the present application for postconviction relief. Following a hearing, the district court denied him relief. We affirm.
On January 30,1981, Heaton was ejected from a bar. When the bar owner later opened the door to see if he had left, Hea-ton fired several shots toward the door. One of the bullets" killed a musician performing in the bar. Heaton was charged with first-degree murder on a felony-murder theory, Iowa Code § 707.2(2) (1981), on grounds that he had murdered the victim while participating in the forceable felony of terrorism,
id.
§ 708.6. He raised a defense of diminished capacity by reason of intoxication but was found guilty of felony-murder. At the postconviction hearing and now on appeal, Heaton charges that the State’s use of the felony-murder charge denied him due process. He further claims his trial attorney rendered ineffective assistance of counsel. We now turn to those issues.
I.
Due process.
Petitioner contends the State’s use of a felony-murder charge denied him due process because the underlying felony, terrorism, and the homicide were one and the same act. He asserts that elevation of the homicide to first-degree murder “on the sole basis of an assault included within the homicide itself in effect relieved the State of the burden of proving an intentionally and knowingly caused death.”
*431
In an opinion filed this same day we have decided the due process issue raised by petitioner. In
State v. Ragland,
420 N.W. 2d 791, 794 (Iowa 1988), we determined that the felony-murder rule does not violate due process when the underlying felony is willful injury under Iowa Code section 708.-4.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit