New York Supreme Court November 15, 1988 (Fisher v. Biderman)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1988

*805OPINION OF THE COURT

Edward H. Lehner, J.

The issues raised herein are: (i) whether it is illegal, in a contract between the City of New York and a private firm for supervision and repair services in city-owned buildings, for the city to agree to indemnify the firm against claims arising as a result of the firm’s negligence, and (ii) whether plaintiffs, who are insurance brokers, have standing to challenge the validity of the contract in a taxpayer suit.

FACTS

The city, acting through the Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD), entered into a contract with Gotham Building Maintenance Corp. (Gotham) for maintenance and repair services in buildings acquired by the city through tax foreclosure. Presently HPD manages approximately 37,000 units of housing in 3,600 such buildings. Gotham employees are trained by HPD, which exercises supervision and control over wages and other conditions of their employment, including the right to discharge.

The contract currently requires Gotham to provide liability insurance, the cost of which is borne by the city through a pass-along provision. This has allegedly resulted in premium payments by the city of over $5 million annually. However, a clause in the contract, which is the subject of this controversy, provides that at HPD’s request Gotham shall terminate its liability insurance and the city will thereafter indemnify Gotham against claims for injury to persons or property occurring during the performance of the agreement, including claims resulting from negligent acts of Gotham. Intentional torts are excluded from the indemnity. The city estimates, from its experience in analyzing claims made against the insurer, that by implementing the right to terminate the insurance policies it will save $3 million annually, and it has stated that it intends to exercise that right.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Plaintiffs assert that the indemnification provision violates General Obligations Law §§ 5-322.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.