Supreme Court of Georgia April 19, 1989, 46359 (Aultman v. United Bank of Crawford)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-04-1989
Hunt, Justice.
C. F. Aultman, Jr. borrowed from the United Bank of Crawford in order to buy a piece of property, which he offered as security for the note. The bank also required that W. L. Stackler, a regular customer of the bank, co-sign the note. When Stackler died and the note became due, the note was paid from the proceeds of a life insurance policy Stackler had assigned to the bank, and the bank assigned the note and security deed to his estate. Aultman then sued the bank and Stackler’s executor to cancel the. security deed. His position was, and is, that payment by Stackler, a co-maker, extinguished the debt leaving nothing to be assigned. The trial court accepted proof that Stackler was a surety and determined, consequently, that the security deed was not released by the payment and was properly assigned to the estate. Aultman appeals and we affirm.
1. Aultman argues it was error to allow parole evidence to prove Stackler signed the note as a surety when the note unambiguously reflects he signed as a co-maker. OCGA § 10-7-45 provides that “[i]f the fact of suretyship does not appear on the face of the contract, it may be proved by parol, . . . .” The statutes and cases relied upon by Aultman are distinguishable as they are applicable only when the defense of suretyship is asserted by one who is primarily obligated on the note in an action brought by the
payee
or his assign to collect on the note. That prohibition does not apply under the circumstances of this case and, therefore, Stackler’s estate may prove he was an accommodation party. OCGA § 11-3-415 (3).
1
2. Aultman follows up his first argument by asserting that even if Stackler were a surety, payment of the note by one who, like Stackler, was primarily responsible to the payee, extinguished the debt and the security was automatically released. Ordinarily, payment which extinguishes the debt is that made at or after maturity by one who is the principal debtor.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit