South Dakota Supreme Court October 18, 1989, 16423, 16427 (Matter of Estate of Erdmann)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-10-1989
HENDERSON, Justice.
PROCEDURAL HISTORY/ISSUES
The South Dakota Department of Revenue (Department) appeals a final order issued by the Circuit Court for Brown County on September 8,1988. This order directed the Department to refund excess inheritance taxes paid on behalf of a minor, Krystal Erdmann (Krystal), during administration of the estate of LeRoy H. Erd-mann, deceased.
The Department, by notice of appeal (No. 16423), alleges that the circuit court erred in two respects:
1) The circuit court lacked jurisdiction to consider Krystal’s claim; and,
2) SDCL 15-2-22, the tolling statute for those under disabilities, including minors, is inapplicable.
By notice of review (No. 16427), Krystal asserts two alternate grounds for relief in her favor:
1) Relief was justified under SDCL 15-6-60; and,
2) SDCL 10-41-84, if not tolled by the provisions for minors in SDCL 15-2-22, violates the “open courts” provision of the South Dakota Constitution (Art. YI, § 20).
CASE HOLDING
We reverse. The crux of this controversy is that application for inheritance tax refund was 30 days late. SDCL 10-41-84 is jurisdictional in nature and SDCL 15-2-22 has no application to these facts. As the trial court lacked jurisdiction to consider the matter, SDCL 15-6-60 is also inapplicable. We further find no conflict between Art. VI, § 20, and SDCL 10-41-84.
FACTS
LeRoy H. Erdmann died intestate on August 11, 1983, survived by his wife, Gail, and his daughter, Krystal, aged 2. Gail was appointed administratrix of his estate. As administratrix, Gail filed an Inheritance Tax Report and Inventory in the circuit court on February 25,1985, which indicated that the estate had a net value of $4,991,-648.48. According to this report, Krystal was to receive $2,364,677.74, subject to South Dakota estate tax of $173,600.83. The report showed an additional $420.00 in tax due on the shares of Ora Erdmann and Geneva Erdmann, who were LeRoy’s parents.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit