Supreme Court of Vermont January 13, 1989, 84-176 (Buzzell v. Jones)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-01-1989
*5
Allen, C. J.
The defendant appeals from a judgment in favor of plaintiff George Buzzell for injuries he received on defendant’s land while fleeing from her dogs.
The defendant lives on a mostly wooded 100 acre parcel of land that is uninhabited except for her home. She owned two dogs, a malamute and a border collie. The former had shown no dangerous tendencies, but the latter had bitten visitors on several occasions.
The plaintiff was a county forester and went to the defendant’s property at her request to inspect her woodlot in connection with a federal cost-sharing program. He accompanied defendant through a twenty-acre stand of trees and marked ones that in his opinion should be cut. He recommended that she hire a private forester to do the required work. It was understood that she would inform the plaintiff when the work was completed so that he could inspect the woodlot to certify if it qualified for the cost-sharing program.
The defendant informed the plaintiff’s secretary that the work had been completed, and the plaintiff later arrived unannounced at defendant’s home to inspect the work. When he was unable to find the defendant, he went alone to the woodlot. Defendant and the two dogs were in another section of the property. When the dogs discovered the plaintiff they barked and ran after him. The border collie bit his left leg and the plaintiff injured his kneecap while attempting to flee the attack.
Two crucial related matters were in dispute at trial. The defendant testified that she warned the plaintiff that her dog would bite and that she told the plaintiff before the first visit that she had to know when he was coming because “she had to put the dog away.” She further testified that when she telephoned to advise that the work was ready for inspection she told the plaintiff’s secretary that she had to know the exact day and time that the plaintiff was coming so that she could secure the dog before he came.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit