Court of Special Appeals of Maryland April 27, 1989, 998, September Term, 1988 (Turgut v. Levine)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-04-1989
KARWACKI, Judge.
This case commenced with the filing of a medical malpractice claim in the Health Claims Arbitration Office by the appellee, Anne Christine Levine, in December of 1985. A hearing was held in January, 1987, before a Health Claims Arbitration panel which resulted in a unanimous award in favor of the appellant, Dr. Oguz Y. Turgut. Appellee rejected that award and brought an action to nullify the award in the Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County. On November 25, 1987, a jury returned a verdict in favor of appellee against appellant in the amount of $300,000. Dr. Turgut appeals from the judgment entered on that verdict. He poses two questions for our review:
I. Did the trial court commit error by restricting the defendant doctor’s allowable testimony to non-expert
*282
testimony, so as to severely prejudice the defendant’s presentation of his case?
II. Did the trial court erroneously exclude evidence of Dr. Turgut’s past success/failure rate with the repair technique he chose?
Since we view the two contentions raised by appellant as logically intertwined, we shall discuss them as a single issue.
FACTS
Appellant delivered appellee’s baby girl on June 20, 1982, at Anne Arundel General Hospital. Prior to delivery, appellant made an incision at the opening of the vagina on the rectal side, an episiotomy, in order to facilitate delivery of the baby. When signs of fetal distress developed, a forceps delivery was necessary, resulting in a fourth degree laceration through the mother’s rectum. This extension of the episiotomy was repaired by the appellant and the appellee was kept at Anne Arundel General Hospital for several days postpartum.
On October 2, 1982, the appellee visited Dr. Turgut’s office complaining of some discomfort. Appellant diagnosed appellee as suffering from a rectovaginal fistula
1
and scheduled her for surgery. On October 26, 1982, appellant performed a rectovaginal fistula repair on appellee.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit