Court of Appeals of Kentucky March 10, 1989, No. 88-CA-1308-S (Bingham v. Commonwealth, Natural Resources & Environmental Protection Cabinet)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-03-1989

HOWARD, Judge.

In this case, the owner of a mining company appeals from a summary judgment granted by the Franklin Circuit Court upholding a civil penalty assessed against him *78for mining violations. The appellant claims that he had no notice of the administrative proceedings.

The appellee, Natural Resources and Environmental Protection Cabinet, issued a noncompliance citation to the appellant, Steve Bingham d/b/a Steve Bingham Mining, on January 21, 1986. A preliminary hearing on the matter was held on May 7, 1986. In his report, the hearing officer stated that the Cabinet offered proof that notice of the preliminary hearing had been served, but Bingham failed to appear, seek a continuance or file pleadings. The hearing officer found that Bingham had waived any right to contest the noncompliance order and recommended a civil penalty of $2,100.

An order was issued on June 19, 1986, which stated the hearing officer’s report had been mailed to Bingham and a formal hearing had not been requested within 30 days of the mailing. Bingham’s right to a formal hearing was therefore deemed waived and the civil penalty was ordered due and payable.

The Cabinet filed a complaint in Franklin Circuit Court alleging that Bingham had failed to pay the $2,100 penalty. The Cabinet asked that a judgment be granted in its favor regarding the $2,100. In addition, the Cabinet sought $5,000 civil penalty against Bingham, pursuant to KRS 350.-990, for failure to comply with the order. On May 26, 1988, the trial court granted the Cabinet's motion for summary judgment and ordered Bingham to pay $7,100 in civil penalties plus interest and filing fees.

Bingham contends that he did not receive notice of the preliminary hearing and thus he was deprived of right to due process.

Notice of the preliminary hearing was sent to Bingham by certified mail pursuant to 405 KAR 7:090 § 6(3). The record does not contain the letter or the return receipt. Bingham asserts that the letter was not claimed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.