Court of Appeals for the First Circuit March 15, 1989, 88-1418 (Antonio Dimillo v. Sheepscot Pilots, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-03-1989

SELYA, Circuit Judge.

Like Aeschylus’ much-persecuted hero, defendant-appellant Sheepscot Pilots, Inc. (SPI) bemoans the tempest and proclaims itself wronged. But as Zeus rejected the appeals of the chained Prometheus, we must deny SPI relief save only in a single small respect.

I

By consent, this case was tried to a magistrate, sitting without a jury.

See

28 U.S. C. § 636(c). The findings of fact contained in the ensuing rescript,

DiMillo v. SPI,

No. 86-0241P (D.Me. Dec. 1, 1987), aptly elucidate the contours of the litigation. We summarize them succinctly.

Plaintiff-appellee Antonio DiMillo was an entrepreneur with a nautical bent. He ran a thriving seafood restaurant from a converted ferry anchored in Portland harbor. He wanted to operate a floating hotel as well, and hit upon the idea of converting a barge to that end. Suitable candidates were in short supply. Eventually, DiMillo found the barge of his dreams (the Greenwood), but there was a hitch: she was in Detroit.

As the record verifies, DiMillo was nothing if not resourceful. At substantial cost, he arranged a split tow: a midwestern firm would tow the barge from Detroit to Montreal; SPI would then tow it from Montreal to Portland. The first part of the odyssey went like clockwork. The Greenwood arrived in Montreal shipshape. Defendant’s captain, David Winslow, met the barge with a tug and a crew of five on October 12, 1985. They inspected the Greenwood and found everything to be in order. The second phase of the operation then began. The tug and its charge proceeded without untoward incident down the St. Lawrence River, through the gulf, and into the strait separating Nova Scotia from Cape Breton Island. Early in the morning of October 15, a Tuesday, the party arrived in Port Hawkesbury.

At this point, the evidence diverges.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.