Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit March 28, 1989, 88-1042 (Keith Farrell, William Murray and Richard Richardson v. Automobile Club of Michigan)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-03-1989
MERRITT, Circuit Judge.
The issue in this ERISA and state age discrimination case is whether the District Court properly dismissed plaintiffs’ ERISA claim as time barred on the grounds that (1) the plaintiffs had actual knowledge of the ERISA violation more than three years before the action was filed and (2) that the plaintiffs’ previous filing of the action in the Michigan state court did not toll the applicable statute of limitations because the Michigan state court “clearly lacked jurisdiction” over the ERISA claim. Plaintiffs also challenge the refusal of the District Court to assert pendent jurisdiction over their remaining state age discrimination claims. Because we believe that the Michigan court did not clearly lack jurisdiction over plaintiffs’. ERISA claim and that the ERISA statute of limitations was tolled during the pendency of the state action, we reverse the District Court’s ruling that plaintiffs’ ERISA claim is time-barred and remand the cause to the District Court for further proceedings. We affirm, however, the District Court’s refusal to assert pendent jurisdiction over the remaining state claims.
I.
Each of the three plaintiffs, Keith Farrell, William Murray and Richard Richardson, were long-term management employees of defendant, Automobile Club of Michigan. Each accepted a special early retirement package offered by defendant to employees over 55 years of age between July 1 and December 30, 1980. Each claims he was induced to retire by defendant’s misrepresentations that the package was financially advantageous compared to the regular retirement plan.
Plaintiffs filed suit in Michigan state court on August 30, 1983, alleging in Count I, state law fraud and deceit and breach of
*1131
employment contract and in Count II, state age discrimination. On October 24, 1985, over two years later, defendants moved for summary judgment claiming,
inter alia,
that plaintiffs’ state law claim in Count I was preempted by ERISA.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit