Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit December 28, 1989, 89-1130, 89-1404 (Johns-Manville Corporation and Johns-Manville Sales Corporation v. The United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-12-1989

BENNETT, Senior Circuit Judge.

This appeal is from the order and judgment issued by the Claims Court on September 28, 1988, in

Johns-Manville Corp. v. United States,

Nos. 465-83C, 688-83C, and 1-84C, in which the Claims Court dismissed the complaints for lack of subject matter jurisdiction and awarded costs to the United States. We reverse the. award of costs.

BACKGROUND

Johns-Manville Corporation and Johns-Manville Sales Corporation (Manville) filed three cases in the Claims Court seeking indemnification from the United States for amounts paid by Manville to shipyard workers for injuries caused by exposure to asbestos that Manville had supplied to the government. Manville had previously filed similar suits against the government in United States district courts in California and Virginia.

After several years of discovery and pretrial proceedings, and 2 months before trial in one of the cases was scheduled to begin, the Claims Court raised,

sua sponte,

the issue of whether it had subject matter jurisdiction over Manville’s claims in view of the restrictions of 28 U.S.C. § 1500 (1982). That statute provides that the Claims Court shall not have jurisdiction over any claim for which the plaintiff has a suit against the United States pending in any other court.

Subsequently, the Claims Court issued an order dismissing the three actions for lack of jurisdiction over the subject matter.

Keene Corp. v. United States,

12 Cl.Ct. 197 (1987). Rather than entering a judgment of dismissal, the Claims Court certified the jurisdictional issue for appeal pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1292(d)(2) (1982). While the jurisdictional issue was on appeal, a trial on the merits in one of the cases was held in the Claims Court, resulting in a judgment for the defendant.

Johns-Manville Corp. v. United States,

13 Cl.Ct. 72 (1987).

This court affirmed the jurisdictional ruling of the Claims Court in

Johns-Manville Corp. v. United States,

855 F.2d 1556 (Fed. Cir.1988) (per curiam),

cert. denied,

- U.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.