New York Supreme Court August 17, 1989 (Jankovics v. New York Automobile Insurance Plan)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-08-1989

OPINION OF THE COURT

Peter C. Patsalos, J.

Was petitioner insurance broker’s application to increase his allotment of temporary identification cards from 150 to 200 properly denied under the New York Automobile Insur*580anee Plan? This is the rather unusual issue raised by the CPLR article 78 proceeding now before the court.

The salient facts are not in dispute. The New York Automobile Insurance Plan is a quasi-State agency, having as its sole obligation the assignment of motor vehicle insurance coverage to applicants "who are in good faith entitled to but are unable to procure it through ordinary methods” (see, Insurance Law § 5301; Smith, New York Automobile Assigned Risk Plan, appearing in 4 Examination of Insurance Companies, published by NY State Ins Dept [1954]). The Plan is authorized to print numbered temporary identification cards and issue them to brokers, referred to as "producers”, who, in turn, are entitled to issue them to applicants pursuant to the rules of the Plan (see, 15 NYCRR 32.13 [a] [2]; Aetna Cas. & Sur. Co. v Providence Washington Ins. Co., 55 AD2d 924). There is no dispute that "as a broker obtains experience and learns how to use the cards, each license broker is entitled to receive a maximum of 200 per order”. Nor is it disputed that "if a broker desires to have more than one license, that broker can apply to the Insurance Department for an additional license under another name and if approved by the Insurance Department, can receive a maximum of 200 cards with each order for each new licensee”.

In November 1988, petitioner broker sought to increase his order limit of identification cards from 150 to 200 cards. After his request was denied, petitioner instituted the instant proceeding, contending that this denial was "arbitrary and capricious”.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.