Supreme Court of Virginia November 10, 1989, Record No. 890111 (Commonwealth v. National Council on Compensation Insurance)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-11-1989
Chief Justice Carrico
delivered the opinion of the Court.
On June 27, 1988, the National Council on Compensation Insurance (the National Council)1 applied to the State Corporation *515Commission for approval of a 25.2% increase in the overall level of premiums charged for policies of workers’ compensation insurance. The Division of Consumer Counsel, Office of the Attorney General, filed notice of its intention to participate in the proceeding in opposition to the application.
On October 21, 1988, after two hearings, the Commission entered a final order approving a 5.7% rate increase. Consumer Counsel is here on an appeal of right. The sole question for decision is whether the Commission erred in limiting Consumer Counsel’s cross-examination of a staff witness who changed his testimony following the initial hearing on the National Council’s application. Finding that the Commission erred in this respect, we will reverse.
The witness in question, Philip O. Presley, president of an actuarial consulting firm, was retained by the Commission staff. In his prefiled testimony, he stated that an average increase in workers’ compensation rates of only 0.7 % was warranted. Two consultants retained by Consumer Counsel stated in their prefiled testimony that a 1.3% reduction in rates would be proper.
In the initial hearing on the rate-increase application, held September 14-15, 1988, Consumer Counsel, in an opening statement, pointed out that the staffs recommendation of “only a .7 percent increase” and Consumer Counsel’s proposal for a “reduction in the order of 1.3 percent” were “not too dissimilar.” Then, when staff-witness Presley testified and reiterated his recommendation for a rate increase of only 0.7% , Consumer Counsel elected not to cross-examine the witness. Upon conclusion of the hearing on September 15, 1988, the Commission took the matter under advisement.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit