Oregon Supreme Court December 20, 1990, 87-01-21356-L; CA A46889; SC S35734 (Mattiza v. Foster)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-12-1990

*3

CARSON, J.

Upon review in this court, the issue before us is whether the trial court properly awarded defendant attorney fees, pursuant to ORS 20.105(1),

1

after finding that plaintiff had acted in bad faith in bringing and pursuing an action for undue influence. The Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s award of attorney fees. We reverse.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

In 1984, plaintiff, who resided in Texas, visited her 89-year-old aunt Virginia Dare Sandy in Ontario, Oregon. Plaintiff found her aunt unkempt and living in squalor. Concerned about these conditions, plaintiff initiated guardianship proceedings, and in 1985, plaintiff was appointed her aunt’s guardian and conservator of her aunt’s estate. In the course of arranging her aunt’s affairs, plaintiff discovered that, in January 1985, her aunt had purchased a $10,000 certificate of deposit in the name of defendant, then her aunt’s neighbor. Plaintiff became convinced that the $10,000 transfer was the result of defendant’s improper influence over her aunt.

Plaintiff, as conservator of her aunt’s estate, subsequently brought this action

2

in circuit court for return of the $10,000, plus interest. The trial judge made extensive findings of fact and conclusions of law, and held that defendant had not exercised undue influence over plaintiffs aunt. After making the additional finding that plaintiffs claims were asserted in bad faith, the court.awarded $7,620 in attorney fees to defendant.

The Court of Appeals, in a

per curiam

opinion, affirmed the trial court’s judgment, including the award of attorney fees.

Mattiza v. Foster,

93 Or App 619, 762 P2d 1067

*4

(1988). The Court of Appeals’ opinion did not specifically address the attorney fees issue. We allowed review to address the nature of the litigious conduct that allows a court, pursuant to ORS 20.105(1), to assess attorney fees for actions that are taken “in bad faith, wantonly or solely for oppressive purposes.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.