Idaho Court of Appeals March 22, 1990, 17221 (Bean v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-03-1990
combined-opinion
809 P.2d 506 (1990) 119 Idaho 645 Scott D. BEAN, Petitioner-Appellant, v. STATE of Idaho, Respondent. No. 17221. Court of Appeals of Idaho. January 11, 1990. Review Granted March 22, 1990. *507 Marvin R. Stucki, Idaho Falls, for petitioner-appellant. Jim Jones, Atty. Gen. by Lynn E. Thomas, Sol. Gen., Boise, for respondent. BURNETT, Judge. This is a post-conviction relief case. Scott Bean is serving a fixed (determinate) life term of imprisonment for first degree murder. He seeks relief because a codefendant has recanted testimony adverse to him. The issue is whether the recantation "requires vacation of the conviction or sentence in the interest of justice... ." I.C. § 19-4901(a)(4). The district court, focusing primarily upon the conviction, denied relief. Today, for reasons explained below, we uphold the district court's ruling as to the conviction, but we remand the case for additional consideration relating to the sentence. The background facts may be summarized briefly. Bean and his codefendant, William Caudill, were tried jointly on a charge of premeditated homicide, committed by luring the victim to a place where he was stabbed repeatedly. During the trial, Caudill took the witness stand. He testified that Bean had planned the murder and had inflicted virtually all of the victim's wounds. Bean's attorney vigorously cross-examined Caudill about some discrepancies in his story and about his obvious incentive to put the blame on Bean. After the testimony was concluded, there was a conference in the judge's chambers during which Bean said Caudill's testimony had been so harmful that he felt compelled to testify in response. Bean's attorney counseled him not to do so, and Bean eventually followed his attorney's advice. A jury later found both defendants guilty as charged. Caudill received an indeterminate life sentence, making him eligible for possible parole in ten years. Bean, as we have noted, received a fixed life sentence without parole.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit