Court of Appeals of Virginia November 20, 1990, Record No. 0978-89-3 (Wood v. Allison Apparel Marketing, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-11-1990

Opinion

WILLIS, J.

In this appeal, we consider (1) whether the Industrial Commission erred in failing to dismiss the claimant’s application for workers’ compensation benefits upon the employer’s plea of

res

judicata

1

, and (2) whether the finding of the Industrial Commission that the claimant failed to carry the burden of proof imposed by Code § 65.1-46.1 was supported by the evidence. We affirm the decision of the Industrial Commission.

In her June 2, 1988 application, the claimant, Norma Jean Wood, sought compensation from her employer, Allison Apparel Marketing, Inc., for carpal tunnel syndrome disability, which she alleged resulted from an industrial accident on September 19, 1987. By decision dated October 6, 1988, the deputy commissioner denied benefits, holding that the claimant had failed to prove that her disability resulted from an industrial accident. This decision was not reviewed and became final.

See

Code § 65.1-98.

*354

On October 13, 1988, the claimant filed a new application seeking compensation for the same disability, but contending that it resulted from an occupational disease. The employer, by letter of October 18, 1988, addressed to the commission with a copy to counsel for claimant, objected to the new application being heard on the ground that it was barred by the doctrine of

res judicata.

Without ruling on the defense of the doctrine of

res judicata,

the deputy commissioner to whom the matter was referred conducted a hearing and awarded benefits to the claimant. In its application for review, filed March 3, 1989, the employer noted its exception to the deputy commissioner’s finding that the claimant’s second application was not barred by

res judicata

and asked leave to present argument in support of that position. The case was set for hearing before the full commission on May 4, 1989. By letter of April 19, 1989, the employer set forth its position on the merits of the claim.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.