Supreme Court of Iowa March 21, 1990, 89-55 (Preferred Marketing Associates Co. v. Hawkeye National Life Insurance Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-03-1990

McGIVERIN, Chief Justice.

Plaintiff Preferred Marketing Associates Co. (PMA) is an independent insurance agency which represented defendant Hawkeye National Life Insurance Co. (Hawkeye). In June 1984, Hawkeye terminated its contracts with PMA and certain individuals connected with PMA. In July 1986, PMA filed this law action, essentially alleging that Hawkeye had breached its contract with PMA and had tortiously interfered with PMA’s business.

The matter proceeded to trial. Over Hawkeye’s objection, the district court allowed an expert witness to testify regarding calculation of PMA’s damages, despite the fact that PMA had not designated the expert as a witness until one week prior to trial.

After overruling portions of Hawkeye's motion for a directed verdict, the court instructed the jury on several of PMA’s claims. The jury returned special verdicts for PMA on two of the claims, awarding PMA $250,000 for breach of contract and $100,000 for tortious interference with prospective contractual relations. Hawkeye’s

*391

posttrial motions were overruled. The court entered judgment on the verdicts, with interest from the date the suit was filed.

Hawkeye has appealed, arguing that the court erred: 1) in allowing the expert witness to testify; 2) in overruling the motion for a directed verdict on the breach of contract and the tortious interference with prospective contractual relations claims, and; 3) in awarding prejudgment interest under Iowa Code section 535.3 (1987).

The court granted Hawkeye’s motion for a directed verdict on some of PMA’s claims. PMA has cross-appealed from this ruling with respect to its claims of uncon-scionability of contract, conversion, and negligent breach of contract.

Our review is for correction of errors at law. Iowa R.App.P. 4. We conclude that Hawkeye’s motion for a directed verdict on the claim of tortious interference with prospective contractual relations should have been granted. The judgment on that claim, therefore, is reversed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.