Supreme Court of Iowa March 21, 1990, 88-1651 (Killian v. Iowa District Court for Linn County)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-03-1990

HARRIS, Justice.

We granted certiorari to consider this challenge to a trial court ruling which disqualified an attorney from further participation in probate litigation. The court reasoned that the attorney’s representation of a trust beneficiary conflicted with his representation of another beneficiary. We annul the writ.

The case revolves around the relationship between attorney Tom Riley and his clients Joan Killian Hunter (Joan) and John Richard Killian (John).

1

Joan and John were sister and brother and beneficiaries of the Anne Killian trust, an inter vivos trust created by their mother.

In 1983 Joan filed suit in federal court against the Merchants National Bank and Russell Hess, then co-trustees of the trust, alleging mismanagement and breach of fiduciary duty. Tom Riley represented Joan in that action. After extensive discovery the parties agreed upon a settlement. A settlement memorandum was signed by Joan, Riley, Hess and others.

John became implicated in the settlement at the insistence of the Merchants National Bank. The bank would settle with Joan only if there were to be no further litigation involving the Anne Killian trust. Because John obviously was the only other

*428

potential litigant the trust filed a report of its doings, including the settlement with Joan, and had the matter set for hearing in probate court. John was given notice.

Joan’s settlement provided that, if the trust report were not approved, the settlement was voidable at the bank’s option. The report was approved by an order entered April 30, 1987. The settlement agreement contained a provision (paragraph eight)

2

which provides for confidentiality. It also stated that the agreement did not “bar or otherwise limit” the representation of others by Riley. Within a few days of the settlement Riley was retained by John Killian, and Jan his wife, to bring another action against the same defendants, also arising out of the bank’s administration of the Killian trust.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.