Court of Appeals of Georgia September 4, 1990, A90A1150 (Antique Center of Roswell, Inc. v. City of Roswell)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-09-1990
Banke, Presiding Judge.
The City of Roswell initiated condemnation proceedings to acquire certain property in which the appellant held a leasehold interest and on which it had been operating a “flea market” and auto auction business. A special master awarded the appellant $485,000 for its interest, and the city appealed. The case was then tried before a jury, which awarded the appellant only $6,500. The appellant brings the present appeal from the denial of its motion for new trial.
Held:
1. The appellant, contends that the trial court erred in refusing to give its requested charge that it was entitled to recover its moving expenses and relocation costs incurred as a result of the condemnation, “including its costs to advertise and market its new location.” The business had not relocated at the time the case was tried, and the evidence of the appellant’s prospective relocation expenses consisted, in its entirety, of the following testimony offered by the owner on direct examination: “Q. [W]hen you relocate this, what would you think to be reasonable advertising costs at a new location? A. Well, I put in approximately $185,000 in advertising costs [at the original location]. . . . I would think maybe up to a quarter of a million dollars in the new building will be necessary to get this going again. Q. ... Do you have an opinion as to what it would cost you physically just to move what you have got to any other location? A. I think [for] the physical moving, [ten thousand dollars is] probably in the ball park, ten, fifteen thousand dollars to move it. . . .” Pretermitting whether an award of damages for relocation costs, including advertising expenses, would have been authorized in this case on the basis of proper proof thereof, the foregoing testimony was clearly insufficient to support such an award in that it was wholly speculative in nature.
2. The appellant contends that “[t]he trial court committed reversible error when it limited the measure of . . .
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit