Supreme Court of Georgia November 8, 1990, S90A1425 (Tolbert v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-11-1990
Weltner, Justice.
1. (a) John Tolbert was indicted for malice murder, felony murder, aggravated assault, possession of a firearm during the commission of a crime, and escape. Prior to his indictment, the trial court, under authority of Uniform Superior Court Rule 31.5, ordered a mental evaluation. The report of a psychiatrist at Central State Hospital stated that Tolbert had been under the influence of a delusional compulsion at the time of the incidents here involved. Two days before his indictment, Tolbert filed a notice of intent to raise the defense of insanity. On the date of the indictment, the state moved for a psychiatric evaluation. The trial court — after finding that the requirements of OCGA § 17-7-130.1 had been met and that it was not necessary to appoint an independent psychiatrist or psychologist — ordered that the state might require Tolbert to be examined by a psychiatrist of its choice. We granted interlocutory review.
(b) Tolbert contends that he had complied with a state-requested psychological evaluation, which was performed by the state’s expert; that the results of the first evaluation were exculpatory; and that he may not be compelled to undergo a second mental evaluation at the behest of the state.
2. (a) “Whether to grant the motion [for a second psychiatric examination] was in the discretion of the trial court . . . [cit.].”
Smith v. State,
245 Ga. 44, 46 (2) (262 SE2d 806) (1980). That determination “will not be overturned unless an abuse of discretion is shown. [Cit.]”
Cunningham v. State,
248 Ga. 558, 560 (4) (284 SE2d 390) (1981).
*528
Decided November 8, 1990.
Daniel J. Sammons,
for appellant.
C. Andrew Fuller, District Attorney,
for appellee.
(b) When Tolbert filed notice of his insanity defense, the court was required under the terms of OCGA § 17-7-130.1 to appoint “at least one psychiatrist or licensed psychologist to examine the defendant and to testify at the trial.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit