Supreme Court of Colorado March 19, 1990, 88SC309 (Ravin v. Gambrell, by and Through Eddy)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-03-1990

combined-opinion

788 P.2d 817 (1990) Sheldon J. RAVIN, D.O., and David R. McKee, D.O., Petitioners, v. Daniel GAMBRELL, a minor, By and Through his mother and best friend, Linda Gambrell EDDY, and Linda Gambrell Eddy, personally, Respondents. No. 88SC309. Supreme Court of Colorado, En Banc. March 19, 1990. *818 Johnson & Mahoney, P.C., Collie E. Norman, Denver, for petitioner Sheldon J. Ravin, D.O. Pryor, Carney and Johnson, P.C., Kathie Fliss Martell, Englewood, for petitioner David R. McKee, D.O. Peter A. Goldstein, P.C., Peter A. Goldstein, Colorado Springs, for respondents. James S. Bertagnolli, Colorado Springs, guardian ad litem for Daniel Gambrell, a Minor. Sherman and Howard, W. David Pantle and Steven D. Plissey, Denver, for amicus curiae Bank Western Federal Sav. Bank. Justice KIRSHBAUM, delivered the Opinion of the Court. In Gambrell v. Ravin, 764 P.2d 362 (Colo.App.1988), the Court of Appeals held that the trial court erroneously denied a motion for new trial filed by Daniel Gambrell and his mother, Linda Gambrell Eddy (respondents). The Court of Appeals held that respondents were entitled to a new trial because improper communications occurred between the jury and a bailiff during jury deliberations and because the trial court erred in refusing to instruct the jury on the issue of res ipsa loquitur. Having granted petitions for writ of certiorari filed by petitioners Sheldon J. Ravin and David R. McKee to review these issues, we now affirm and remand the case with instructions. I When Linda Gambrell Eddy (Eddy) became pregnant in the fall of 1978, she decided to use the LaBoyer method[1] of natural childbirth. She engaged the services of David R. McKee, a licensed doctor of osteopathic medicine, and McKee made arrangements for delivery in the birthing *819 room[2] of Eisenhower Hospital in Colorado Springs. In July 1979, McKee participated in National Guard maneuvers. He referred Eddy and his other patients to Sheldon J.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.