Court of Appeals of Virginia February 27, 1990, Record No. 1696-88-4 (Seneca Falls Greenhouse & Nursery v. Layton)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-02-1990

Opinion

MOON, J.

Seneca Falls Greenhouse & Nursery and Florists Mutual Insurance Company seek reversal of an award of compensation and disability payments to Charles G. Layton. We affirm the award because we find credible evidence to support the commission’s decision.

The first issue deals with Rule 2(A) of the Industrial Commission which provides that the request for review “should specify each determination of fact or law to which exception is taken,” and must be made within twenty days of the deputy’s decision. Appellants argue that the deputy commissioner found that Charles G. Layton was suffering from an ordinary disease of life and did not sustain an injury by accident. Appellants contend that the only issue before the full commission was whether claimant was suffering from a compensable occupational disease.

In claimant’s request for review, claimant took exception to the deputy’s finding that (1) “the employee’s anxiety/panic attack is an ordinary disease of life, and (2) the medical records amply demonstrate that Charles G. Layton’s pre-existing panic disorder

*484

was aggravated by his work-related exposure to Resmethrin and that Resmethrin did not organically cause Mr. Layton’s symptoms but was a result of [a] psycho-organic syndrome.”

Appellants argue that this review request did not sufficiently specify an exception to the finding of fact that there was no compensable injury and, therefore, the commission erred in reversing the deputy’s finding of fact and in finding that there was a compensable injury. Although Mr. Layton’s appeal did not expressly challenge the finding that there was no injury by accident, we find that, in questioning the finding of fact that he suffered an ordinary disease of life, he likewise implicitly questioned the finding that he did not sustain a compensable injury. We hold, therefore, that the full commission did not err by granting Mr. Layton’s request for review.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.