Idaho Court of Appeals April 5, 1990, 17868 (Chester v. State Farm Insurance)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-04-1990
BURNETT, Judge.
This appeal presents issues relating to an insurance contract and the tort of bad faith. Dalice Chester, a farmer, sued the State Farm Insurance Company, seeking payment of insurance proceeds after the destruction of his barn by fire. In addition, he sought damages for State Farm’s alleged bad faith delay in processing his claim. On summary judgment, the district court determined the amount owed to Chester, interpreting the insurance policy to cover replacement cost of the destroyed property. A jury trial followed on the issue of bad faith, resulting in a verdict for Chester. State Farm filed this appeal, challenging both the summary judgment and the jury verdict. For reasons explained below, we vacate the summary judgment on the replacement cost issue and remand the case for further proceedings. We affirm the judgment on the jury verdict independently finding bad faith delay by the insurance company.
The underlying facts are as follows. Dalice Chester contracted with State Farm for insurance coverage on his barn. Later, he asked State Farm’s agent, Paul Ward, to increase the coverage on the barn in order to protect the personal property inside. There is some dispute as to the amount by which coverage was subsequently increased. In January, 1985, the barn and its contents were destroyed by fire. Chester filed a claim and was informed that by the terms of his policy, he was entitled only to the actual cash value of the barn — at most, $50,000. Chester informed State Farm that he believed his policy entitled him to the replacement cost of the barn, up to $95,000. State Farm offered Chester the actual cash value of the barn as part of a settlement. Chester refused the offer and brought this suit.
Both parties filed cross-motions for partial summary judgment on the issue of whether the insurance policy provided for the barn’s full replacement cost as opposed to the actual cash value.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit