Idaho Court of Appeals March 13, 1990, 17858 (Roselle v. Heirs and Devisees of Grover)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-03-1990

SWANSTROM, Judge.

Clay Roselle of Lima, Montana, appeals a district court order dismissing his claims against the heirs and devisees of Archie Grover (hereinafter the Grover heirs). This is the third lawsuit involving Clay Roselle and the Grover heirs. We agree with the district court that the final judgments in the two previous actions are a bar to the claims presented here. Accordingly, we affirm the order of the district court.

In 1978, Pierce Roselle, Clay’s brother, brought an action against the Grover heirs to quiet title to real property located in Clark County, Idaho. (Case I) Eventually, the parties — through their attorneys — stipulated to the entry of a judgment on July 28, 1986, which quieted title in the Grover heirs. The judgment adopted a certain sur

*531

vey as the true boundary line between land belonging to Pierce Roselle and land belonging to the Grover heirs and established responsibilities for certain fencing along property lines. Although he had not been a party to that action, Clay Roselle immediately filed a request for a hearing to set aside the judgment, claiming to have an interest in the property. A month later Pierce Roselle moved for relief from the judgment. The court denied these requests in a decision filed October 14, 1986. No appeal was taken in Case I.

The controversy over the property did not end there. Clay Roselle continued to dispute the Grover heirs’ ownership and possession of the real property. He recorded a deed from his brother, Pierce, purporting to give him an interest in the property. Clay Roselle also built a fence upon the disputed property. This interference prompted the Grover heirs to bring an action against the Roselle brothers in May 1987 to again quiet title to the parcel of real property. (Case II) The Grover heirs also sought damages for trespass and slander of title. In that action, the district court granted a motion for partial summary judgment quieting title in favor of the Grover heirs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.