Supreme Court of New Jersey July 18, 1990 (State v. Benedetto)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-07-1990

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

GARIBALDI, J.

This appeal presents a narrow question regarding the “state of mind” exception to the hearsay rule,

Evid.R.

63(12)(a). The issue is whether the trial court committed prejudicial error in admitting certain hearsay statements of the victim recounting threats he had perceived because of an overdue debt that he owed defendant’s father. The Appellate Division, which ruled that such statements were expressions of fear exeludible under

State v. Machado,

111

N.J.

480, 545 A.2d 174 (1988), reversed defendant’s murder conviction and remanded the matter for a new trial. We granted certification 117

N.J.

73, 563 A.2d 835 (1989), and now reverse the Appellate Division.

I

During the early morning hours of October 6, 1986, Anthony Mautone was shot and killed in his garage recording studio in Newark, N.J. An investigation disclosed that Mautone had died at approximately 3:00 a.m. from a single .32 caliber gunshot wound to the back of his head fired at close range. His body had been found lying on the floor in front of his stereo. Shortly thereafter, Ronald Benedetto, Jr. was charged with his murder.

1

The theory of the State’s case was that Benedetto lured Mautone to the studio on the pretext of a drug exchange and killed him because of a debt Mautone owed Benedetto’s father.

*253

On the previous evening, Sunday, October 5, 1986, Mautone had been working as a disc jockey at Society Hill, a Morristown night club. Ordinarily, Mautone would visit with his girlfriend, Anna Prassinos, at the club and then afterward at her home before returning to Newark. Prassinos testified that shortly after midnight on October 6, Mautone had received a phone call at the club. Mautone had later told Prassinos that the caller had been Benedetto, Jr., asking that Mautone meet him after work to sell him cocaine. After a second telephone call, Mautone had told Prassinos that he could not go to her house that night because he had to meet Benedetto, Jr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.