District Court of Appeal of Florida October 11, 1990, 88-3069 (Faucher v. RCF DEVELOPERS)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-10-1990
569 So.2d 794 (1990) Claude J. FAUCHER, Appellant, v. R.C.F. DEVELOPERS D/B/a Madhatter Mufflers & Brakes and Mutual Insurance Company, Appellees. No. 88-3069. District Court of Appeal of Florida, First District. October 11, 1990. James M. Callan, Jr., Clearwater, for appellant. Cleve A. Wilson of Butler and Burnette, Tampa, for appellees. ZEHMER, Judge. We review by appeal a workers' compensation order denying the claim of Claude J. Faucher for temporary total or partial disability benefits and medical benefits on the ground that he did not suffer an injury in the course of his employment with appellee, R.C.F. Developers d/b/a Madhatter *795 Mufflers & Brakes. Concluding that the record lacks competent, substantial evidence to sustain the findings upon which the judge of compensation claims based his ruling, and finding error in the admission in evidence of the deposition testimony of a witness, Beth Champagne, on purely collateral matters relating to claimant's credibility not shown to be relevant to the issues being tried, we reverse and remand for further proceedings. Claimant contends that he injured himself on March 2, 1988, while lifting a bucket of heavy steel rollers as he was cleaning an area of his employer's shop. The filled bucket weighed at least 185 pounds, and claimant testified that he alone attempted to lift it but could not, so his foreman, Richard Stackhouse, helped him move it several feet to another location. Claimant insists that when he stood up after moving the bucket, he felt pain in his lower back and made a comment about it to Stackhouse. Stackhouse denies that claimant made such a complaint at the time, and states that he did not learn of the complaint until several days or weeks later (his testimony is indefinite about the time periods). Claimant also insists that within a few days after the incident he told his employer, Richard Fisher, about hurting himself when lifting the bucket of rollers; Fisher disputes this.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit