District Court, N.D. Alabama August 6, 1990, Civ. A. 89-AR-1482-M (Walker v. Anderson Electrical Connectors)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-08-1990

MEMORANDUM OPINION

ACKER, District Judge.

Plaintiff, Ann Walker, was permitted, in response to the jury verdict of June 19, 1990, to suggest to the court by special motion what judgment should be entered on that verdict. The pre-trial posture of the case is set out in

Walker v. Anderson Electrical Connectors,

736 F.Supp. 253 (N.D.Ala.1990), and need not be repeated.

At this juncture, defendant-employer, Anderson Electrical Connectors, is understandably no longer complaining about the jury trial of a Title VII case (at least not in

this

case). This court, nevertheless, cannot resist a short addendum to its series of opinions holding that the parties to a Title VII case are entitled, upon demand, to trial by jury on the money issues, including the “back pay” issue, which many courts have described as a form of equitable relief thereby avoiding the Seventh Amendment issue. On April 10, 1990, a district court in Montana held: “Congress, in enacting the ADEA, did not abrogate the states’ eleventh amendment immunity from suit in federal court and, consequently, the eleventh amendment precludes an award of back pay against a state thereunder.”

Black v. Goodman,

736 F.Supp. 1042, 1045 (D.Mont.1990). It is, of course, a well understood principle that the Eleventh Amendment provides states immunity from claims for legal relief but not from appropriate

equitable

relief. By finding the State of Montana immune from a claim for “back pay,” the court was necessarily finding that “back pay” constitutes a legal remedy. It would be an impermissible anomaly for “back pay” to be a legal remedy under the ADEA but an equitable remedy under Title VII. If “back pay” is a legal remedy, the Seventh Amendment clearly controls who shall make the factual determinations.

After this case was submitted to the jury which Walker had demanded over defen

*593

dants’ strenuous objection, the jury answered special interrogatories as follows:

1.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.