District Court of Appeal of Florida November 27, 1990, 89-1534, 89-1533 (Community Bank of Homestead v. Valois)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-11-1990

570 So.2d 300 (1990) COMMUNITY BANK OF HOMESTEAD, a Florida Corporation, Appellant, v. Charles M. VALOIS, Doris R. Valois, His Wife, and Ocean Reef Shores, Inc., a Florida Corp., Appellees. Nos. 89-1534, 89-1533. District Court of Appeal of Florida, Third District. November 27, 1990. *301-303 Allison Doliner Hockman, John R. Sutton, Miami, for appellant. Frank, Schmitt & Frank and Michael Frank, North Bay Village, for appellees. Before BASKIN, FERGUSON and GERSTEN, JJ. ON PETITION FOR REHEARING BASKIN, Judge. Community Bank of Homestead appeals the entry of a final judgment denying its claim for deficiency judgment and awarding one dollar as nuisance damages against Charles M. Valois, Doris Valois and Ocean Reef Shores, Inc. (collectively Valois). We affirm. Valois executed a note in favor of Community Bank secured by a mortgage of certain real property. Valois defaulted, and the bank instituted a foreclosure action. The trial court entered a judgment of foreclosure against Valois, and, on July 16, 1987, the bank purchased the property at foreclosure sale for a successful bid of $100. In December, 1987, the bank sold the property to Dr. Frederick Poppe, trustee, for $180,000 plus the realtor's commission. Subsequently, the bank instituted an action for a deficiency judgment. The bank and Valois stipulated that the debt owed totalled approximately $220,000. The bank presented evidence that it purchased the property at foreclosure sale for a nominal bid, that it resold to Dr. Poppe for $180,000 and that the fair market value of the property when it was resold in December 1987, approximately five months later, was $202,000. Valois introduced evidence that the fair market value of the property as of the date of foreclosure was $318,000. Finding that the resale price was less than fair market value, the listing price, or the appraisal, and that the resale was not an arm's length transaction, the trial court denied the claim for a deficiency judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.