District Court, D. Colorado September 5, 1990, Civ. A. 89-C-7 (Miller v. Ibarra)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-09-1990

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

CARRIGAN, District Judge.

The legal representatives of four aged, infirm and mentally incompetent women commenced this lawsuit in an effort to extricate their charges from the “Utah Gap.” That is the popular nomenclature for a “Catch 22” in state health care policy that deprives many senior citizens of Medicaid payments for nursing home expenses to which they are otherwise entitled. When their incomes are too low to enable them to pay their own nursing home costs, but too high to qualify for Medicaid benefits, these claimants are ensnared in a trap created by the interaction of highly technical federal and state statutes and regulations. They are not allowed to pay as much as they can, and have Medicaid pay the balance, but instead are totally disqualified for any Medicaid assistance.

Plaintiff L. Jeanette Miller, as representative plaintiff for Lottie Bernice Ham, and intervenors Susan Turtness Adams, as representative plaintiff for Marie Louise Turtness,

1

Mary J. Henry, as representative plaintiff for Mary D. Cummings, and Larry Tasei,

2

as representative plaintiff for Maria S. Tasei commenced this suit seeking reversal of the Colorado Department of Social Services’ decisions to deny their charges Medicaid benefits. Specifically, the plaintiff and the intervenors (“plaintiffs”)

3

seek: (1) a declaratory judgment that income rendered unavailable by virtue of judicially imposed trusts created pursuant to Colo.Rev.Stat. § 15-14-409 (1987), may not be considered the patient-beneficiary’s income for purposes of determining Medicaid eligibility under 42 U.S.C. § 1396a(a)(17) and 9 Colo.Code Regs. § 3.200.21 (1979); and (2) an injunction forbidding the defendant from continuing to treat income held in such trusts as “available” for purposes of determining eligibility for Medicaid. Defendant is Irene Ibarra, Executive Director of the Colorado Department of Social Services.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.