District Court, E.D. Wisconsin August 2, 1990, Civ. A. 89-C-265 (Coats v. Luedtke Engineering Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-08-1990

DECISION AND ORDER

REYNOLDS, Senior District Judge.

FACTS

In April or May of 1987, plaintiff William Coats (“Coats”) began to work for defendant Luedtke Engineering Company (“Luedtke”) as a crane operator on board the vessel, Derrick Boat II (“DB II”). Coats was hired to use the crane to unload dredge material from barges and drop it on shore in a fill area. Luedtke provided Coats with access to and egress from the DB II by having Coats walk on a breakwater to where the DB II was moored. A filter cell was located along the breakwater which Coats would have to climb through in order to reach the DB II. In order to pass through the filter cell, Coats would have to use two three-step ladders which were located at both ends of the cell. On July 13,1987, Coats was injured while passing through the filter cell and using a ladder on his way to the DB II.

On June 15, 1990, this court heard oral argument by the parties on the numerous

*887

motions pending in this action. During the hearing, this court granted Coats’ motion for leave to amend its complaint. This court notes that some of the parties’ motions are to dismiss or in the alternative for summary judgment. The Seventh Circuit has held that if materials outside of the pleadings are presented to and considered by a district court, then the court should treat the motion as one for summary judgment.

Hill v. Trustees of Indiana University,

537 F.2d 248, 251 (7th Cir.1976). This court has considered materials presented to the court outside of the pleadings in deciding the numerous motions, and therefore when appropriate the motion is considered as one for summary judgment.

Here is a list of the claims and motions relating to them, and this court’s decision on each motion:

A. Coats’ Claims:

1. Coats’ claim v. Luedtke under the Jones Act;

* Luedtke’s motion for summary judgment is DENIED;

2. Coats’ claim v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.