District Court, District of Columbia February 13, 1990, Civ. A. 88-2529 (Edens v. Musolino)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-02-1990

ORDER

REVERCOMB, District Judge.

On September 16, 1985, the Defendant, Harry W. Musolino, and Plaintiff, Virginia E. Edens, were involved in an automobile accident. Defendant Musolino was operating a 1985 Chrysler LaBaron owned by the Defendant Heritage Chrysler Plymouth Sales, Inc. Defendant Heritage contends that Defendant Musolino was operating the vehicle without its permission and accordingly it has no liability in this matter.

This matter is before the Court pursuant to the motion of Defendant Heritage for summary judgment.

Under the Motor Vehicle Safety Responsibility Act, D.C.Code §§ 40-401 et seq. (1981), a driver of a motor vehicle is presumed to have the consent of the owner. D.C.Code § 40-408. This presumption may be rebutted by a showing by the defendant of uncontradicted proof that the vehicle operator was not, in fact, operating the vehicle with the owner’s consent or permission.

Miller v. Imperial Ins., Inc.,

189 A.2d 359 (D.C.1963). When there has been such evidence presented, the defendant is

*534

entitled to judgment as a matter of law.

Curtiss v. Cuff,

537 A.2d 1072 (D.C.1987).

Defendant Heritage relies upon a “rental agreement” which it entered into with James Himsel. Under the terms of this agreement Himsel was the only authorized driver of the vehicle and operation by a party other than the authorized driver constituted a breach of the rental agreement. Accordingly, Defendant Heritage argues that it has presented uncontradicted proof that it did not grant permission of Defendant Musolino to use the car.

However, there is a dispute as to whether such an agreement was in effect at the time of the accident. There are three dates on the document but the only that is legible

1

provides “ENTERED Sep 24 1985” which does not coincide with the date of the accident at issue. Moreover, this Court can infer no meaning as to this date from the document. Although Defendant Heritage in its Answers to Interrogatories provides that “Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.