District Court, D. Kansas November 1, 1990, 88-4125-R (Lee v. Bartlett and Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-11-1990

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

ROGERS, District Judge.

This is a bankruptcy appeal. Debtors filed their bankruptcy petition on October 21, 1985. This matter arises from a complaint for turnover filed by debtors on October 22, 1987. In this complaint, debtors allege that Bartlett and Company, a grain elevator, agreed to purchase wheat that was delivered by Serena Saylor, but never paid for the wheat. Bartlett and Company argued in return that Serena Saylor refused to accept a joint payee check for the wheat, and that it was agreed the wheat would be stored pending a decision as to whom the check should list as a payee. Therefore, storage charges should be deducted from the purchase price of the grain, according to Bartlett and Company.

After an evidentiary hearing, the bankruptcy court held that there originally was a contract of sale for the grain, but the contract became one of storage because the manner of payment for the grain was unacceptable to Serena Saylor. The bankruptcy judge offered to sign an order directing the turnover of the price of the wheat minus storage charges or to sign an order dismissing the complaint. Ultimately, an order dismissing the complaint was signed.

Debtors have appealed from that order. The following issues have been raised on appeal: 1) whether the bankruptcy court erred in refusing to admit evidence offered by the debtors at the hearing; 2) whether the bankruptcy court erred in refusing to take judicial notice of statutes and regulations of the United States at the hearing; 3) whether the bankruptcy court erred in refusing to allow counsel for the debtors to argue and cite statutes, laws and regulations of the United States; and 4) whether the bankruptcy court erred in its application of the laws to the evidence in granting judgment for the defendant.

It is agreed that this court should apply a

de novo

standard to the bankruptcy court’s conclusions of law and a clearly erroneous standard to the bankruptcy court’s findings of fact.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.