United States Bankruptcy Court, D. Montana March 2, 1990, 17-60904 (In Re Marshall)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-03-1990

ORDER

JOHN L. PETERSON, Bankruptcy Judge.

After due notice, hearing was held January 16, 1990, on confirmation of the Debtors’ Fourth Modified Chapter 13 Plan, together with the objections of National First Mortgage Corporation (NFMC), and the Chapter 13 Trustee. Also heard were the Debtors’ Objection to the Proof of Claim of NFMC, Motion to Value Collateral of NFMC, Motion to Avoid NFMC’s Lien, and Motion for Disallowance of Unsecured Portion of NFMC’s Claim. Prior to hearing a Stipulation was filed between the Debtors and NFMC which settled the valuation issue, valuing the Debtors’ residence at $56,-500.00.

*326

The Debtors, in their Fourth Modified Chapter 13 Plan and through their Motions, are proposing to pay NFMC only on the portion of their debt that is secured. NFMC has filed a Proof of Claim as a secured creditor in the amount of $77,-009.12. NFMC contends that it is entitled to a secured claim of $56,500.00, and an unsecured claim of $20,509.12. The Debtors contend that NFMC is not entitled to an unsecured claim. The Debtors contend that NFMC’s claim can be bifurcated under the holding of

In re Hougland,

886 F.2d 1182, 1185 (9th Cir.1989). In

Hougland,

the Court held that § 506(a) and § 1322(b) are not in conflict and that a claim secured in property by “real property that is the Debtor’s principal residence” may be bifurcated into a secured and an unsecured claim.

1

NFMC objects and resists the Debtors’ Motions and Plan, but NFMC does not dispute that its claim may be bifurcated under

Hougland.

Accordingly, based on the agreement as to the value filed between the parties, NFMC has a secured claim of $56,500.00 and an unsecured claim of $20,509.12.

In re Glenn,

796 F.2d 1144, 1147 (9th Cir.1986);

Hougland,

supra, at 1185.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.