District Court, D. Oregon April 10, 1990, 88-868 RE (Defrees v. US, Through US Forest Service)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-04-1990

OPINION

REDDEN, District Judge.

Plaintiffs Ellen, Lyle, and Lowell De-frees bring this action under the Federal Tort Claims Act alleging that defendant United States Forest Service negligently failed to suppress a forest fire that damaged their property. The parties agreed to bifurcate trial of liability and damages. The liability phase was tried to the court on March 27 and 28, 1990. I find that defendant is not liable for plaintiffs’ damages.

BACKGROUND

Plaintiffs own land adjacent to Forest Service land within the Burnt Powder Fire Zone of the Wallowa-Whitman National Forest, near Baker, Oregon. Between 2:00 and 4:00 p.m. on Saturday, August 2, 1986, unpredicted dry thunderstorms passed through Eastern Oregon, starting twenty to thirty fires in the Burnt Powder Fire Zone. Because numerous fires also started in other parts of the Wallow-Whitman National Forest and on an adjacent National Forest, there was competition for fire suppression resources in the area.

One of the fires in the Burnt Powder Fire Zone, referred to as “incident 31” and later named the Huckleberry Fire, is the subject of this litigation. The Huckleberry Fire started more than three miles to the west of plaintiffs’ property. Two roads and Huckleberry Ridge, a natural fire break, separate plaintiffs’ property from the point where Huckleberry Fire started.

With the exception of incidents 41 and 42, known as the Coronet Fire, on August 2 the Forest Service assigned personnel and equipment to all the fires it had located that started in the Burnt Powder Fire Zone. A three-person crew, supervised by Robert DeMastus, who was experienced in forest fire suppression, arrived at the Huckleberry Fire at about 5:00 p.m. When the crew arrived, the fire was between one and two acres. DeMastus and his crew, which included Bill Mitchell, also experienced in fire suppression, dug an 18 to 24 inch wide line around the fire.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.