Court of Appeals of Maryland February 7, 1990, 139, September Term, 1988 (Becker v. Litty)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-02-1990

ADKINS, Judge.

Boone Creek is a tidal estuary located near Oxford, Talbot County, Maryland.

1

A somewhat tortuous channel at its mouth leads to the Choptank River. The Creek is divided into what are known as the North and Southeast Branches. At the confluence of these branches is Sol’s Island, containing perhaps as much as five acres of land. A bridge spanning the roughly 240 feet from Sol’s Island to the mainland is the focus of controversy in this case, which raises, among other issues, important questions of riparian rights, the preemptive effect of a United States Coast Guard bridge permit, and standing. We shall resolve these issues, but, because the record before us clearly does not reflect a number of matters that bear on the ultimate disposition of the case, we shall remand under Maryland Rule 8 — 604(d), for further proceedings.

I. Facts

In May 1986, appellee Suzanne Hanks Litty acquired title to Sol’s Island, then an essentially uninhabited tract of land accessible only by air or via the waters of Boone Creek. She and her husband, appellee Ernest Litty (the Littys), decided to build a residence on the island. They also decided, it seems, that an aerial or aquatic commute would have its drawbacks. In October 1986, the Littys obtained a United States Coast Guard permit to build a private, one-lane, fixed bridge across the aforesaid 240 feet between Sol’s Island and the mainland. The permit specified that the bridge should have three feet of vertical clearance over Boone Creek at mean high water.

Although the Coast Guard had given public notice of the application for the bridge permit, and also had notified

*80

certain federal and State agencies, some of the Littys’ Boone Creek neighbors did not become aware of the situation until after the permit had issued. When they learned of the permit, those neighbors lost no time in protesting to the Littys, the Coast Guard, and others. Déspite these objections, the Littys actively prepared for erection of the bridge.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.