Indiana Court of Appeals December 17, 1990, 63A01-9006-CV-232 (Phegley v. Indiana Department of Highways)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-12-1990
ROBERTSON, Judge.
Richard L. Phegley appeals the denial of his petition for judicial review by which he sought the reversal of the Indiana Department of Highways' (IDOH) decision to demote him from District Maintenance Engineer to Highway Engineer III, reinstatement and back pay.
We affirm.
Phegley served as Vincennes District Maintenance Engineer, classified as a Highway Engineer Supervisor IV, from January 1, 1970 until December 4, 1986 when he was demoted to Highway Engineer III, a position with no supervisory responsibilities. Prior to the demotion, on September 30, 1986, the IDOH reprimanded Phegley in writing for discussing personnel matters with persons outside the IDOH. Phegley received an employee appraisal report at the same time which indicated that his performance in employee relations was less than satisfactory. Pheg-ley's immediate supervisor recommended that Phegley be demoted on November 24, 1986, after Phegley authored what was perceived by his supervisor to be an inflated performance appraisal of a subordinate.
Phegley received a pre-demotion hearing and a full review hearing following the demotion before an administrative law judge appointed by the then-director of IDOH. The ALJ recommended that Pheg-ley be demoted. The IDOH adopted the ALJ's proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law. Phegley then sought judicial review. The reviewing court sent the matter back to the IDOH for a hearing on Phegley's petition to introduce newly discovered evidence. The IDOH concluded that the July 14, 1987, IDOH memorandum sought to be introduced by Phegley did not apply to Phegley and would not change the outcome of his administrative appeal. The Pike Cireuit Court 'affirmed the IDOH's determinations.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit