Supreme Court of Iowa January 24, 1990, 88-1485 (D & C Express, Inc. v. Sperry)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-01-1990
HARRIS, Justice.
Larry Sperry sought workers’ compensation benefits after he slipped and fell from his tractor-trailer. Sperry claimed to have been employed by D & C Express, an Iowa corporation which hauls steel products throughout the country. D & C Express defended on the ground Sperry was an independent contractor rather than an employee. The industrial commissioner awarded benefits.
1
On judicial review the award was sustained but ordered reduced by the district court. We affirm.
In 1983 Sperry was the owner-operator of a semitrailer truck. He leased it to D & C Express under a written agreement which required Sperry to provide his vehicle and a driver to operate it. Sperry was required at all times to display D & C signs on his truck. Sperry was responsible for the licensing costs, maintenance costs, and for maintaining liability insurance on his equipment. He was also to maintain his own health and workers’ compensation insurance.
Sperry paid the salary of any other drivers who might assist him out of the “wages” D & C paid him. Sperry was required to check daily with D & C but was free to choose his travel routes. He was allowed to “trip lease” (contract with other shippers) if D & C did not have freight available for return trips. Sperry operated only his own unit, never any of the units owned by D & C.
D & C, as lessee, was required to see that all the leased equipment met all federal safety regulations, that cargo was insured, and that drivers maintained proper logs. D & C assigned shipments to leased owner-operators such as Sperry on a first come first served basis.
D & C paid Sperry weekly by check which designated the payment as “wages.” Sperry was paid seventy-eight percent of the gross revenues of all freight hauled for D & C and ninety-four percent of the gross revenue he received from other carriers. Sperry estimated that twenty-five percent of the seventy-eight percent paid pursuant to the agreement was compensation for his services.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit