North Dakota Supreme Court July 3, 1990, Cr. 890326, 890327 (State v. Blumler)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-07-1990

VANDE WALLE, Justice.

The State of North Dakota appealed from an order of the district court which granted Eugene Richard Blunder's motion to suppress evidence seized from his home pursuant to a search warrant. Because we conclude that the warrant was issued as the result of an illegal search and was therefore invalid, we affirm the order suppressing the evidence seized pursuant to the invalid warrant.

In April of 1989, the unoccupied rural home of Gerald and Marsha Offner was burglarized. A green and white, old-fashioned cookstove and several barstools were taken from the home. The Offners reported the burglary to the Barnes County Sheriff’s Department.

On May 2, 1989, at approximately 11:00 p.m., Deputy Randy McClaflin of the Barnes County Sheriffs Department attempted to serve civil process upon Eugene Blunder at his residence in Sanborn, North Dakota. Blunder's residence is a multistory home with an attached garage. There are at least three outer entrances to the Blunder home. The east side of the residence contains a front door and a sliding-glass patio door. The north side of the home has a walk-in door which enters into the attached garage. Inside the garage there is an inner-door which leads to the kitchen of the residence.

When Deputy McClaflin arrived at the Blunder residence to serve the civil papers, he elected to use the entrance which would require him to pass through Blunder's garage. Both the large, overhead garage door and the walk-in door were closed at

*301

the time. Without knocking or seeking any other type of invitation, McClaflin opened the walk-in door and entered the garage. Because it was dark, McClaflin turned on his flashlight and proceeded to the kitchen door. When no one responded to his knock, Deputy McClaflin turned to leave and the beam

of

his flashlight shone upon á green and white cookstove which was sitting in the garage. After observing the stove, McClaflin returned to his vehicle and left the premises.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.