South Dakota Supreme Court August 1, 1990, 16739 (State v. Davis)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-08-1990
PER CURIAM.
As part of a plea agreement, Gene A. Davis, Sr. (Davis) pled guilty to receiving stolen property. His sentence included the requirement that he make restitution to the victim. Davis appeals the restitution portion of his sentence. We reverse and remand.
FACTS
On July 12, 1988, Black Hills Findings, Inc. was . burglarized and approximately $3900 in guns, knives and jewelry were taken. A portion of the property was recovered at Davis’ home, while other stolen property, valued at approximately $2836 has never been recovered.
Davis was charged with receiving stolen property. A plea agreement was reached and Davis pled guilty to receiving stolen property. Davis was aware, when he accepted the plea agreement, that restitution could be required but the probable amount of restitution was not discussed or agreed upon.
Davis was sentenced to three years in the state penitentiary and was ordered to pay $2893.59 in restitution. Davis argued that restitution should be limited to the value of the property related to the crime to which he pled guilty and since that property had all been recovered, no restitution should be imposed. The trial court rejected that argument and decided that restitution should be imposed in the amount of all unrecovered property taken in the burglary. Davis appeals that determination.
DECISION
Davis pled guilty to receiving stolen property. He was never charged with burglary, nor did he admit committing burglary. The state argues that Davis agreed to full restitution and should be held to his bargain. Davis argues that he should not be required to pay restitution for a crime which he was never charged with and did not admit. We agree with Davis and reverse the restitution portion of his sentence.
The policy of the restitution statutes of this state is to assure that criminals make restitution to the “victims of [their] criminal activities to the extent that the violator is reasonably able to do so.” SDCL 23A-28-1.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit