New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division August 8, 1990 (State v. Marshall)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-08-1990

244 N.J. Super. 60 (1990) 581 A.2d 538 STATE OF NEW JERSEY, PLAINTIFF, v. GREGORY MARSHALL, DEFENDANT. Superior Court of New Jersey, Law Division Essex County. Decided August 8, 1990. *63 Debra G. Lynch for plaintiff (Herbert H. Tate, Jr., Essex County Prosecutor, attorney). Thomas O'Gorman for defendant. NEWMAN, J.S.C. This petition for post-conviction relief raises an issue of first impression; namely, whether a petitioner may challenge, in this State, the constitutionality of a foreign conviction, which was used to enhance his sentencing by this court, when the foreign conviction is not presumptively void. Petitioner Gregory Marshall has moved for post-conviction relief, pursuant to R. 3:22-2(c), on the ground that he was sentenced in excess of, or otherwise not in accordance with, that authorized by law. Petitioner, convicted of armed robbery in 1983 and sentenced as a persistent offender to a term of 30 years with a parole ineligibility term of 15 years, offers three arguments in support of his motion: first, that a 1968 conviction in the State of Oklahoma stems from a constitutionally defective plea bargain and was therefore improperly used to enhance his New Jersey sentence; second, that the State's motion to impose an extended term had been improperly served; and third, that, at the time of the original sentencing, this court improperly balanced aggravating and mitigating factors and relied upon a materially inaccurate presentence report. The *64 last of these arguments has already been raised, and rejected, and need not be discussed here.[1] The first and second arguments, however, are new and merit analysis and will be addressed in reverse order. Petitioner submits that he had no knowledge of the State's motion to impose an extended term until the day of sentencing. In an alleged violation of R. 3:21-4(d) and denial of due process, petitioner states that this motion was served, not personally, but only upon his attorney.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.