Supreme Court of Pennsylvania December 14, 1990, 01257 (Trackers Raceway, Inc. v. Comstock Agency, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-12-1990

combined-opinion

400 Pa. Superior Ct. 432 (1990) 583 A.2d 1193 TRACKERS RACEWAY, INC., Appellant, v. COMSTOCK AGENCY, INC., a Corporation; Allied Specialty Insurance, Inc., a Corporation; American Columbus Insurance Company, a Corporation; T.H.E. Insurance Company; Southwestern Fire and Casualty, a Corporation; John Branish; and Harold Churns, an Individual, Appellees. Supreme Court of Pennsylvania. Argued May 31, 1990. Filed December 14, 1990. *434 Peter Molinaro, Jr., Pittsburgh, for appellant. Michael L. Magulick, Pittsburgh, for Comstock & Branish, appellees. Arthur J. Murphy, Jr., Pittsburgh, for Allied Specialty, appellee. Before ROWLEY, WIEAND, OLSZEWSKI, MONTEMURO, BECK, KELLY, POPOVICH, JOHNSON and FORD ELLIOTT,[*] JJ., En Banc. OLSZEWSKI, Judge: In this case, we are asked to decide whether an order dismissing two out of five counts of a complaint is an immediately appealable final order. We must therefore also examine the doctrine of appealability announced in the seminal case of Praisner v. Stocker, 313 Pa.Super. 332, 459 A.2d 1255 (1983). Applying the Praisner standard, we conclude that the trial court's order dismissing counts IV and V of appellant's complaint is final and appealable. *435 The factual history of the case is as follows. In 1987 appellant, Trackers Raceway, Inc., filed a five-count complaint against appellees, Comstock Agency, Inc.; Allied Specialty Insurance, Inc.; American Columbus Insurance, Inc.; T.H.E. Insurance Company; Southwestern Fire and Casualty, Inc.; John Branish and Harold Churns. The complaint alleged a number of facts. Trackers is a go-cart track operator, regulated by the Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture. Departmental regulations mandated that insurance coverage of the track be written only by insurers authorized to do business in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Trackers sought to obtain insurance coverage in mid-1986.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.