Appellate Court of Illinois May 16, 1990, 5-88-0092 (Bollman v. Perry Manor, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-05-1990

JUSTICE HOWERTON

delivered the opinion of the court:

Eva May Smith died. Her will provided for a legacy to “PERRY MANOR, INC., Pinckneyville, Illinois.”

Perry Manor, Inc., a Nevada corporation, operated a nursing home called Perry Manor in Pinckneyville. Before Eva May Smith died, Perry Manor, Inc., sold the nursing home in Pinckneyville to Lifecare Center of Pinckneyville, Inc. Lifecare continued to operate the nursing home in Pinckneyville and continued to call it Perry Manor.

Smith’s executor filed a petition to construe the will, claiming that there was a latent ambiguity, saying that the apparent intention of Eva May Smith was to make a charitable bequest in support of the operation of the nursing home in Pinckneyville, not for the general purpose of the corporation Perry Manor, Inc.

The circuit court dismissed the petition. Lifecare appeals. We affirm.

We ignore the portions of the executor’s petition that purport to know the intention of Eva May Smith. Those statements are speculative. To consider them as creating a latent ambiguity would have the same effect as rewriting the will.

In determining the propriety of the circuit court’s dismissal of the executor’s petition, our sole task is to determine whether the factual allegations of the petition to construe the will set forth facts which, if proved, would create a latent ambiguity in the will. (Wooded Shores Property Owners Association, Inc. v. Matthews (1976), 37 Ill. App. 3d 334, 345 N.E.2d 186; Goldberg v. Ruskin (1984), 128 Ill. App. 3d 1029, 471 N.E.2d 530.) We, therefore, are to compare the allegations of the petition to the provisions of the will.

If the petition to construe the will states facts which, if proved, show a latent ambiguity, then a hearing must be held in which evidence extrinsic to the will is taken to determine if there is a latent ambiguity. If it is determined that no latent ambiguity exists, then the petition is dismissed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.