Massachusetts Appeals Court September 28, 1990, 89-P-860 (National Amusements, Inc. v. City of Boston)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-09-1990
Kass, J.
Although all rational presumptions favor the validity of an amendment by a municipality of its zoning code, we decide that the amendment of the Boston Zoning Code presented for review arbitrarily singled out the land of the plaintiff National Amusements, Inc. (“National”), for disparate treatment from similar land in the same zoning area. Accordingly, we affirm the decision of the Land Court judge
*306
which came to the same conclusion and adjudged the zoning amendment invalid. National brought its complaint in the Land Court under G. L. c. 185, § 1
(j½),
and G. L. c. 240, § 14A.
The judge made extensive findings of fact, for which there is support in the record.
The Locus
National’s property consisted of a vacant 13.8 acre tract lying westerly of Veterans of Foreign Wars Parkway (“VFW Parkway”) in the West Roxbury section of Boston. In former years, National had used the site for an outdoor movie theater. At the time of the rezoning under review, the locus was zoned for general business (zoning classification B-l), except for a strip around 125 feet deep along VFW Parkway, which was zoned for local business (zoning classification L-.5).
On the easterly boundary of the locus is VFW Parkway and thereafter the B-l district extends for a considerable distance on the other (i.e., easterly) side of VFW Parkway. In that section of B-l zone there are a small shopping center (dominated by a Heartland supermarket), office buildings, an apartment condominium, a gas station, a furniture store, an electric power transmission facility (northerly of the railroad tracks), and a nursing home.
Northerly, the locus is bounded by the road bed of the Needham branch of the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority commuter railroad, and north of that road bed, in an S-.3 (single residence) district, are the West Roxbury High School and several cemeteries. Northwesterly is a closed city dump site located in an 1-2 zoning district (general manufacturing).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit